eBay ’95 Shop

💌 Looking for more?  SIGN UP HERE  for our FREE weekly newsletter featuring more NYC events, guides, exclusive giveaways, and discounts!

If you’re looking for a can’t-miss moment in NYC, eBay is opening the ’95 Shop, a retail pop-up and online storefront curated by ’90s icon and star of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Sarah Michelle Gellar. From Pokémon to Prada, fans can score the most-searched items from the decade starting at just 95 cents.

Whether you’re a sneakerhead, Pokémon master, vintage fashion collector, or sports fan, there’s something for everyone to shop from eBay’s “greatest hits” – a collection of iconic fashion, collectibles, and motors pieces from the ’90s that continue to shape culture today – inspired by eBay marketplace data and curated through Sarah Michelle’s lens as a cultural icon from the decade.

All shoppers at the ebay ’95 Shop will receive an eBay branded tote bag with purchase, along with being given out at their swag station.

The “greatest hits” represent some of the most memorable items from the era that have captured the hearts of collectors for 30 years and still top fans’ wishlists to this day, including:

• Air Jordan XI Concord Sneaker: Widely ranked among the greatest sneakers ever, the GOAT’s eleventh signature sneaker saw a 35% surge in searches following the December release of the “Legend Blue” colorway (Dec 2024 vs. Nov 2025).
• Spider-Man 1 Gold Torment Variant Signed by Stan Lee and Todd McFarlane (CGC 9.8): This comic sold over 2.5 million copies in the ’90s, and comic book fans still love Spidey, as Amazing Spider-man topped eBay’s most-searched superhero series in its Comic Books and Memorabilia category during the first half of 2025 (Jan-June 2025).
• 1993 Topps Derek Jeter Rookie Card (PSA 10): This gem mint Derek Jeter rookie card is an icon for collectors whose interest translates to more than 400 searches per hour for The Captain on eBay in 2025 (Jan-June 2025).
• Gianni Versace Motorcycle Leather Jacket Worn by Prince: An iconic 1995 piece from the Gianni Versace Autumn/Winter collection, famously worn by Prince and captured by Richard Avedon in a striking campaign image. With the fashion world still buzzing after Prada’s high-profile acquisition of the brand this spring, vintage Versace has never felt more relevant or desirable.

The auction of the “greatest hits” will commence on September 3rd at 9 am here, with all proceeds benefitting Make-A-Wish.